State and local governments are increasingly targeting the hidden climate impact of construction through policies aimed at reducing "embodied carbon"—the greenhouse gas emissions associated with manufacturing, transporting, and installing building materials. These emissions occur before a building is even occupied but constitute a significant portion of its total lifetime carbon footprint. To address this, policymakers are primarily adopting two distinct strategies: procurement standards, often known as "Buy Clean" policies, and direct amendments to building codes. While both aim to promote the use of low-carbon materials, they operate through different mechanisms and affect different sets of construction projects. Understanding these approaches is crucial for construction professionals and public officials navigating the evolving landscape of sustainable building.
Comparing Embodied Carbon Policy Mechanisms
The two main strategies for regulating embodied carbon in construction—procurement standards and building code amendments—differ significantly in their scope, mechanism, and application. Procurement policies leverage a government's purchasing power to create a market for low-carbon materials, primarily affecting public projects. In contrast, building codes set mandatory requirements for a much broader range of private and public construction projects within a jurisdiction. According to RMI, cities are leveraging these and other strategies to meet their climate commitments by integrating embodied carbon reduction goals into their overall policy frameworks. The fundamental distinction lies in whether the policy uses market incentives driven by public spending or direct regulatory mandates for the entire construction sector.
| Feature | 'Buy Clean' Procurement Standards | Building Code Amendments |
|---|---|---|
| Policy Type | Procurement policies that integrate low-carbon requirements into government purchasing for public projects. | Direct regulatory changes to building codes that set limits on embodied carbon for construction within a jurisdiction. |
| Mechanism | Uses the government's role as a major purchaser to create demand for materials with lower greenhouse gas emissions. | Establishes mandatory, enforceable limits on the embodied carbon of materials or entire buildings. |
| Primary Target | Materials purchased for publicly funded construction projects, such as infrastructure and government buildings. | All new construction and major renovation projects that fall under the jurisdiction of the building code, including private developments. |
| Example Implementation | A state requiring material suppliers for a public project to meet specific greenhouse gas reduction benchmarks. | The City of Portland's requirement setting maximum Global Warming Potential (GWP) values for specific concrete mixes used in city-solicited projects. |




